Compare
Free shipping
Best price guarantee
Special pricing
Financing with Resolve
Easy returns
Last updated 12/27/2024 - Originally published 12/27/2024
Written by SimpleTire
Vercelli Tires and Starfire Tires are two popular tire manufacturers known for their versatility, good quality, and affordable tires. Vercelli is a sub-brand of American Omni Trading and offers tires designed for year-round traction and sure-footed handling and performance. On the other hand, Starfire is a part of the Cooper Tire family and focuses on quality, durability, and performance at an affordable price. Both tire manufacturers offer a range of tires for different fitments in various categories such as all-season, all-weather, summer, UHP, highway, all-terrain, and so on.
All-season tires are designed for use on passenger and commercial vehicles and offer drivers superior year-round traction, enhanced longevity, and a quiet, comfortable ride. These tires are popular among daily drivers as they are meant to be driven on long commutes and are the most common tire type on the road today. Today, we will be looking at two great all-season tires from the brands - Vercelli II and Starfire Solarus AS. Both tires are designed to be used on passenger cars. We will be looking at some of the similarities and differences between the two tires in this Vercelli II vs Starfire Solarus AS tire comparison.
Vercelli II tires
The Vercelli II is an all-season tire designed for use on performance-oriented coupes and sedans and offers high-speed stability with quick braking and acceleration. The tire features a twin center rib design with a smart tread pattern, and a computer-optimized design to deliver great all-round performance. You can also see a 45,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty.
Thanks to these features, the Vercelli II was given an average SimpleScore of 8.1 out of 10.
Starfire Solarus AS tires
The competitor, Starfire Solarus AS, is also an all-season tire best suited for passenger vehicles, CUVs, and SUVs, and offers drivers impressive traction and performance in wet, dry, and light winter weather conditions. The tire features a special siping design, deep lateral grooves, and an enhanced rubber compound, all working in harmony to ensure robust performance. Here you can see a 50,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty.
The Starfire Solarus AS delivers a solid performance and received a solid SimpleScore of 7.9 out of 10.
Vercelli II vs Starfire Solarus AS tires on traction
When you're in the market for tires, it's crucial to prioritize traction. This factor dictates how effectively your tires grip the road, whether it's wet or dry, ensuring optimal control while driving. Traction plays a pivotal role in various aspects of driving safety, including braking efficiency, resistance to hydroplaning, and overall maneuverability. The capability of a tire's traction is shaped by a combination of factors, including its tread pattern, design, and the formulation of the rubber compound, all working harmoniously to enhance performance.
In traction, the Vercelli II scored a 7.8, which is a solid score thanks to the smart tread pattern that boosts traction and handling performance at high speeds. The twin center rub design further enhances grip on wet and dry roads.
When comparing both tires on traction, you can see Starfire Solarus AS delivers a solid 7.7 thanks to the special siping design that creates additional biting edge and deep, lateral grooves that ensure all-season traction.
In this neck-to-neck competition, you can see the Vercelli II receiving a slightly better SimpleScore making it the winner here.
ADVANTAGE: Vercelli II
Vercelli II vs Starfire Solarus AS tires on handling
When selecting tires, handling stands out as a pivotal factor to consider, as it directly impacts your ability to control the vehicle, especially when driving at higher speeds. Superior handling ensures smooth maneuverability, and seamless lane changes, and enhances the overall driving experience. This aspect is shaped by various elements, including the design of the tread, the composition of the rubber, and the incorporation of advanced technology into the tire's construction.
The Vercelli II truly excels in handling with a great 8.6 and will ensure high-speed stability and braking performance thanks to the win center rib design.
In handling, the Starfire Solarus AS is again a step behind with a score of 8. The symmetrical tread pattern and solid construction help boost the control and handling of the tire.
Here again, you see the Vercelli II taking the lead with a much better SimpleScore.
ADVANTAGE: Vercelli II
Vercelli II vs Starfire Solarus AS tires on longevity
Longevity is a top priority for drivers when selecting tires, as it directly impacts the distance they can cover on a single set. With ongoing usage, tread gradually wears down, underscoring the significance of tires that offer prolonged longevity to maintain peak handling and traction over the long haul. Factors including tread design, rubber formulation, and tire construction collectively influence the tire's lifespan.
In longevity, the Vercelli II scored a solid 8.1 thanks to the computer-optimized tread design that reduces uneven wear for a longer tread life and also helps in offering a quiet, comfortable ride. You can also see a mileage warranty of 45,000 miles with Vercelli II.
The Starfire Solarus AS takes the lead in longevity with a score of 8.4 thanks to an optimized rubber compound that ensures maximum tread life out of the tire. Designed to withstand uneven tread wear, the Starfire Solarus AS is also backed by a 50,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty.
For longevity, the Starfire Solarus AS comes on top with a better SimpleScore and mileage warranty.
ADVANTAGE: Starfire Solarus AS
When to use each
Both Vercelli II and Starfire Solarus AS are all-season tires designed for use on passenger vehicles. These tires offer great traction on wet, dry, and light winter weather conditions, and can be driven year-round.
However, these tires are not designed to be used in moderate to heavy winter weather conditions, where dedicated winter tires are more suited. Additionally, as both these tires are backed by an extensive mileage warranty, they will ensure a long tread life with quiet, comfortable drive on paved roads.
Which one should you choose?
So which all-season tire might be the right choice for you? Well, the answer depends solely on your personal preference as both tires have their set of advantages and disadvantages. While both tires offer great traction, handling, and longevity, a few key factors can help you determine the right fit for you. For instance, the Starfire tire scores better in longevity and mileage warranty. However, the Vercelli tire offers better overall SimpleScore, traction, and longevity.
Another important factor to consider here is the price. The Vercelli II is priced at $74.99 per tire or $299.96 for a set. On the other hand, the Starfire Solarus AS is priced at $85.96 per tire or $343.84 for a set. (Note - Prices may vary depending on the tire size)
Based on SimpleScore, you should choose Vercelli II if you:
- Drive a car like the Audi Q5 Allroad or something like the Chevrolet Camaro
- Want a tire with better overall SimpleScore (8.1 v 7.9), handling (8.6 v 8), and traction (7.8 v 7.7)
- Want a set of tires that offers great performance at a slightly lower price
Based on SimpleScore, you should choose the Starfire Solarus AS if you:
- Drive a car like the Kia Optima, or a Mazda 3
- Want a set of tires with better longevity (8.4 v 8.1) and mileage warranty (50,000 v 45,000 miles)
- Are willing to pay slightly more for a set of tires that will last you longer
Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents will be more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.