Compare
Free shipping
Best price guarantee
Special pricing
Financing with Resolve
Easy returns
Last updated 5/13/2025 - Originally published 5/13/2025
Written by SimpleTire, Expertly reviewed by Brett Antosh
Toyo is a Japanese tire manufacturer that debuted in 1945. Entering the US market in 1966, the brand offers tires for use on passenger cars, light trucks, CUVs, SUVs, EVs, and ATVs/UTVs. The variety of tires offered by Toyo in the US region includes all-season, all-weather, all-terrain, rugged-terrain, UHP all-season, mud-terrain, highway, track competition, and UHP summer.
On the other hand, Yokohama is another Japanese tire manufacturer that was established in 1917. Headquartered in Tokyo, the tire manufacturer offers tires for use on passenger cars, CUVs, SUVs, light trucks, and commercial vehicles. Its portfolio is loaded with all-season, all-weather, all-terrain, mud-terrain, UHP summer, UHP all-season, highway, sport, winter, racing, and commercial van tires.
Both Toyo and Yokohama offer value-for-money tires, which do not compromise on performance, and that’s the reason why they have a huge fan base in the American subcontinent. Coming from these manufacturers, the Proxes Sport A/S+ and the Advan Sport A/S Plus are the two capable ultra-high-performance (UHP) all-season tires that offer a punchy performance like the UHP summer tires and offer the convenience of year-round use like the all-season tires. The use of innovative advanced technologies, tread designs, and features makes the Proxes Sport A/S+ and the Advan Sport A/S Plus tires capable enough to deliver exceptional performance in dry, wet, and light snow conditions.
But, which one of the two is better out the these two and can offer superior performance with the optimum level of punch? Let’s find out in this Proxes Sport A/S+ and the Advan Sport A/S Plus tires comparison. We have used our proprietary tire rating SimpleScore to compare the overall, traction, handling, and longevity abilities of these tires to give you a fairer understanding.
Toyo Proxes Sport A/S+ tires
Launched in July 2024, the Toyo Proxes Sport A/S+ is a UHP all-season tire that’s made for use on coupes, sedans, CUVs, and SUVs, and offers drivers solid grip and traction in dry and wet conditions, low rolling resistance, improved fuel efficiency, long-lasting tread life, increased braking efficiency, confident cornering, and better overall controllability. It is available in 17- to 20-inch rim sizes and is also covered by a tread life warranty.
Overall, the Proxes Sport A/S+ scores a great 8.8 SimpleScore rating, thanks to its long-lasting tread life, sharper handling response, and solid year-round traction.
Get Toyo Proxes Sport A/S+ tires at the best deals for your vehicle here
Yokohama Advan Sport A/S Plus tires
Introduced in October 2019, the Yokohama Advan Sport A/S Plus is also a capable competitor in the UHP all-season tire’s race and gets an advanced asymmetric tread pattern that boosts performance year-round. Suitable for use on passenger and performance cars, the Advan Sport A/S Plus assures confident handling, stability, and ride control, and its braking efficiency is also great. The tire utilizes many advanced features and technologies to boost performance, and is offered in 16- to 21-inch rim sizes. Additionally, there is an attractive tread life warranty on offer, which makes the Advan Sport A/S Plus a true value-offering tire.
Overall, the Advan Sport A/S Plus gets an impressive 8.9 SimpleScore rating because of its exceptional tread life, impressive traction performance, and agile handling.
Get Yokohama Advan Sport A/S Plus tires at the best deals for your vehicle here
Toyo Proxes Sport A/S+ vs Yokohama Advan Sport A/S Plus tires on traction
Traction is one of the most important areas that needs to be analyzed to know if the tire is good on the surefootedness front or not. It gives you an idea of the tire’s ability to grip the surface and how it is in traction, especially when the tire is rolling in the forward motion. In our traction analysis, we found that both tires were great, however, one of them got a marginal win by a 0.1 additional score. Here’re the details:
First, let’s talk about the Proxes A/S+, the tire is rated an 8.8 SimpleScore in traction, which is good enough to prove that the tire has the potential to serve year-round and deliver great performance. It features a new-gen tread compound that ensures optimum performance and grip in wet and dry conditions, and its dynamic taper design improves grip and traction performance. The optimized asymmetric tread pattern of this tire also gets details in the form of multi-wave sipes across the footprint for better grip in light snow conditions.
On the other hand, the Advan Sport A/S Plus scores a slightly better 8.9 SimpleScore for its commendable traction performance. Thanks to the advanced all-season HS-2 rubber compound and the use of high-grade silica and advanced polymers, the Advan Sport A/S Plus offers solid grip in wet and light snow conditions. There are Z-shaped grooves and multiple sipes on the footprint for increased surface biting ability in wet and light snow weather. Additionally, the four wide circumferential grooves ensure water dispersion from the footprint for reduced risk of hydroplaning and solid wet grip.
In traction, as we hinted at the beginning of this section, the Advan Sport A/S Plus surpasses the Proxes Sport A/S+ by a small margin.
ADVANTAGE: Yokohama Advan Sport A/S Plus
Toyo Proxes Sport A/S+ vs Yokohama Advan Sport A/S Plus tires on handling
Moving on to the handling analysis, let’s try to understand which of the two ultra-high-performance all-season tires is better when it comes to stability, ride control, steering response, braking efficiency, acceleration, cornering, and overall controllability.
Starting with the Proxes Sport A/S+, this tire is rated an 8.8 SimpleScore for its great handling response. The dynamic taper design of this tire enhances handling and braking performance on wet and dry roads, while the ultra-high performance casing construction provides better steering response and maneuvering. The Proxes Sport A/S+ also features an optimized asymmetric tread pattern that ensures improved stability and cornering performance, while the high sipe density increases braking efficiency in light snow conditions. The multi-wave sipes and optimized tread with optimized tread pitch sequencing help in controlling the tread noise levels for an enhanced driving experience.
On the contrary, the Advan Sport A/S gives tough competition to the Toyo UHP all-season tire by securing an equal 8.8 SimpleScore rating in handling. The extra-large blocks on the shoulders for improved cornering and the sidewalls are constructed adequately tough to maintain the tire’s original shape for quicker handling response. Yokohama has used the silica-rich HS-2 all-season rubber compound that enhances braking performance, especially on wet and light snowy conditions, while the wider footprint lets more rubber come in contact with the road for better stability, ride control, and acceleration at higher speeds.
As indicated by the scores of both tires, the Proxes Sport A/S+ and the Advan Sport A/S Plus stand equally good, resulting in a tie!
ADVANTAGE: Tie
Toyo Proxes Sport A/S+ vs Yokohama Advan Sport A/S Plus tires on longevity
Next is longevity analysis, which is important from a buyer's point as it helps in understanding how good a tire is on the service life front, controlling tread wear, and reducing the chances of irregular or premature wear. Here, we saw one of the tires taking the lead to beat the other. Read on for details!
Commencing with the Proxes Sport A/S+, the tire records an impressive 9.0 out of 10 SimpleScore. For long and even wear, it is constructed using an advanced tread compound, and there is an ultra-high casing construction that provides more strength through its high tensile steel belts, stiffer sidewalls, and high hardness bead filler. There are multi-wave sipes that minimize the chances of irregular wear and promote long-lasting performance. Additionally, the Proxes Sport A/S+ is covered by a 50,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty that further confirms its long-lasting service.
Contrarily, the Advan Sport A/S Plus achieves an excellent 9.2 SimpleScore on the longevity front, assuring that the tire offers better service life than its competitor. It gets a flatter contour profile that evenly distributes driving pressures for a longer and even wear, while the use of proprietary HS-2 compound also promotes longevity and reduces the wear rate. There’s a backing of 55,000 miles (for front staggered fitments) limited manufacturer tread life warranty and 27,500 miles (for non-staggered fitments), which confirms that this tire is made with confidence to deliver long-lasting performance.
When both tires are put head to head, it is the Yokohama UHP all-season tire that leads. However, you can deny the fact that the Toyo UHP all-season tire is also good, although it may not score as high as the winner here.
ADVANTAGE: Yokohama Advan Sport A/S Plus
When to use each
Falling in the UHP all-season category, both the Proxes Sport A/S+ and the Advan Sport A/S Plus tires can be used year-round in dry, wet, and light snow conditions. But, as they are not Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified, don’t consider them for driving in severe winter conditions on thick snow or ice, when the temperature remains consistently below 45 degrees Fahrenheit. Additionally, they are suitable for driving only on paved roads and shouldn’t be considered for off-roading purposes.
Which one should you choose?
Looking at overall SimpleScores, the Advan Sport A/S Plus is slightly better than the Proxes Sport A/S+, with an overall score of 8.9 against the latter’s 8.8. However, they both are good in one or the other areas and have their own unique attributes, so consider them before making a purchase.
As far as the prices are concerned, the Proxes Sport A/S+ is offered at a starting price of at least $134 per tire, while the Advan Sport A/S Plus is available at a starting price of at least $136 per tire. This means that a set of four Proxes Sport tires will cost you at least $536, while a set of four Advan Sport A/S Plus tires costs you at least $544. So clearly, price isn’t one of the biggest differentiators here.
Based on SimpleScore, you should consider the Proxes Sport A/S+ if you:
- Drive a vehicle like the Dodge Challenger, Ford Mustang, or Tesla Model 3.
- Need a set of tires that’s equally good in handling (8.8 vs 8.8).
- Want a set of UHP all-season tires for better fuel efficiency.
- Need a set of tires that offer better warranty across all sizes.
On the other hand, you should consider the Advan Sport A/S Plus if you:
- Drive a vehicle like the Nissan 370Z, Toyota Corolla, or Chevrolet Corvette.
- Want a set of tires that offer better traction (8.9 vs 8.8).
- Prefer a set of tires that are long-lasting (9.2 vs 9.0).
- Want a set of tires that are equally good in handling (8.8 vs 8.8).
Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.