Compare
Free shipping
Best price guarantee
Special pricing
Financing with Resolve
Easy returns
Last updated 12/18/2024 - Originally published 12/18/2024
Written by SimpleTire
The Japanese tire manufacturer Toyo was founded in 1945 and makes tires for passenger cars, pickup trucks, SUVs, CUVs, EVs, and ATVs/UTVs. The diversified range of tires offered by Toyo include all-season, all-terrain, all-weather, rugged-terrain, UHP all-season, UHP summer, mud-terrain, and others.
On the other hand, Firestone is the American tire manufacturer, which later became a part of Bridgestone tire family and has been in the business since 1900. The tire manufacturer is OE supplier to many popular car brands and offers tires for passenger cars, farm applications, light trucks, commercial vehicles, OTR applications, and other vehicle types. Firestone’s portfolio also consists of all-season, winter, all-weather, UHP summer, UHP all-season, all-terrain, rugged-terrain, mud-terrain, and others.
In this comparison, we will compare the Celsius Sport and the Weathergrip tires, the two commendable all-weather tires. The purpose of all-weather tires is to serve in dry, wet, and light winter conditions like the all-season tires, and additionally offer the performance in moderate to severe winter conditions because of its Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification. This severe snow certification makes them perform in temperatures below 45 degrees Fahrenheit. Both, the Celsius tires and Weathergrip tires are also severe snow rated all-weather tires and hence, they can be trusted for a year-round use including severe winter.
If you’re in the process of shortlisting an all-weather tire for your sedan, coupe, CUV, or SUV, and have shortlisted Celsius Sport and Weathergrip, our comparative analysis will give you a detailed insight on the tire’s abilities, especially on the traction, handling, and longevity fronts. We have utilized our proprietary tire rating system SimpleScore to give you a fairer understanding of both tires’ performances in the above-mentioned areas on a scale of 0-10. So, read on this Celsius Sport vs Weathergrip tires comparison and choose the tire that fits your driving style and needs better!
Toyo Celsius Sport tires
Let’s begin with understanding the details of Toyo Celsius Sport that was introduced in March 2022. This all-weather tire is designed for use on CUVs, SUVs, and performance-based luxury cars. With severe snow rating, the tire is optimized to outperform the typical all-seasons and offers sharp handling response, year-round traction, and raised driving comfort. The sporty looks helps adding a charismatic character to the vehicle and the tread life warranty makes the ownership experience better. With better braking and cornering performance and long-lasting service life, the Celsius Sport is certainly a worth-considering choice.
Overall, the Celsius Sport bags an admirable 8.6 SimpleScore rating on a scale of 10, thanks to its great handling, longer tread life, and solid traction.
Firestone Weathergrip tires
Now, let’s talk about the Firestone Weathergrip, another contendor in our list that hails from all-weather tire category and was launched in May 2019. The tire is built and designed for use on coupes, sedans, minivans, and CUVs, and is optimized for strong wet performance, enhanced ride comfort, confident snow traction, and serves as a great choice for year-round tire seekers also allowing them to achieve commanding performance in wintry conditions. This all-weather tire, like its counterpart, is also offered with a tread life warranty, which we will discuss in the later section of this review.
Overall, the Weathergrip scores an 8.7 SimpleScore rating, thanks to its outstanding tread life, great traction performance, and responsive handling.
Toyo Celsius Sport vs Firestone Weathergrip tires on traction
Whether it’s about maintaining surefootedness or gauging the tire’s ability to bite the surface for a proper motion in varied weather conditions, the traction analysis becomes crucial. Especially in the case of all-weather tires that are used in diverse weather conditions, the traction assessment because more important for the drivers. So, we compared both tires head to head in the traction area, and found that one of them was marginally ahead of the other by just 0.2 difference. Here’s our traction reading of these tires:
Commencing with the Toyo Celsius Sport, the tire scores an 8.5 SimpleScore in traction and this is an indicator that you will get a dependable traction performance in dry, wet, and severe winter conditions with a set of these tires installed on your drive. Thanks to Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification, the tire is reasonably good for those whoo want something to drive on in severe snow conditions. Similarly, its high-sipe density along with zigzag-shaped tread blocks provide confident traction in all weathers. Lastly, the interlocking multi-wave sipes are also placed optimally for enhanced traction in dry and wet traction.
The Firestone Weathergrip, on the other hand, scores an 8.7 SimpleScore rating in traction. The open shoulder slots on the tread of the Weathergrip enhance water evacuation from the contact patch, while the 3D full-depth sipes are optimize for increased snow traction. The presence of Snow Traction Claw Technology that includes the center and shoulder blocks with snow vices on center ribs further boosts the tire’s performance in slick and snowy conditions.
No doubt, the Celsius Sport tires come with many great abilities to boost traction, the Weathergrip tires win by a slight margin here.
ADVANTAGE: Firestone Weathergrip
Toyo Celsius Sport vs Firestone Weathergrip tires on handling
Tires like the Celisus Sport and Weathergrip that are used in varied weather conditions also must be able to respond to driver’s command and provide confident control. Both the tires were great on this part and again, one of the two surpassed the other and was better in terms of steering response, cornering, lane-changing abilities, and other handling attributes.
The Celsius Sport scores an 8.9 SimpleScore in handling, which means with a set of this tire installed you don’t have to worried of handling and related performance attributes. Thanks to its specialized silica compound, the tire offers optimum ride control in dry, wet, and snow conditions. The solid casing along with asymmetric tread pattern keep the tire in shape for enhanced steering performance and quicker acceleration, while the tread details and shoulders ensure superior braking efficiency and cornering respectively. The tread also houses multi-wave sipes for better snow traction and increased braking performance in wet conditions.
On the contrary, the Weathergrip scores an 8.6 in handling and confirms of its great steering, lane-changing, cornering, and braking efficiencies. While the tire’s wider, flat footprint stabilizes rides, the sipes across the tread ensure that consistent grip is maintained in on the dry, wet, and snowy roads. The shoulders are big enough to contribute to better cornering performance, while the ribs are facilitate in easy change of lanes. Even the optimized silica helps in achieving better control by adapting to the changing temperatures and maintaining the contact.
In handling, it is the Toyo tires that take the lead by a slight marking, leaving the Weathergrip tires behind in the race.
ADVANTAGE: Toyo Celsius Sport
Toyo Celsius Sport vs Firestone Weathergrip tires on longevity
Longevity or long-lasting is another area that’s typically the deciding factor while buying tires and in this area, we found that there difference in the scores of two tires was way more than expected. Here’re are the details:
The Celsius Sport score an 8.6 SimpleScore rating in longevity and is also backed by a 60,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty that signals that the tire is constructed to last longer and offer hassle-free driving experience for at least 60K miles. The reinforced casing along with solid sidewalls, high tensile steel belts, and sturdy bead filler provide adequate rigidity to the tire to withstand pressures. Additionally, the asymmetric tread design of this tire helps in cross-rotation and avoids irregular wear.
Contrarily, the Weathergrip scores an excellent 9.2 SimpleScore rating in long-lasting, confirming that the tire is engineered to cover a good number of miles. It also comes with a 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, which is 5,000 miles more than the tread life warranty of Celsius Sport tires. All thanks to the 3D full-depth sipes, the tire ensures even wear and promotes longevity. Likewise, the solid outer structure and reinforced inner built help the tire serve longer.
It is the Weathergrip tires that strikes again with a lead of 2-1 against the Celsius Sport tires in traction and longevity areas.
ADVANTAGE: Firestone Weathergrip
When to use each
Both tires are severe snow rated and therefore, can be used in dry, wet, and severe snow conditions. It is to be noted that both of them are built for use on paved surfaces and should not be taken on rough road driving.
As far as rim sizes are concerned, the Celsius Sport tires can be considered for vehicle’s having rim size in the range of 17- to 22-inch, while the Weathergrip tires can be considered for vehicles in the rim size range of 15- to 19-inch.
Which one should you choose?
If you look at the overall SimpleScores, it is the Firestone Weather Grip that marginally leads with an 8.7 SimpleScore against the Celsius Sport’s 8.6 SimpleScore rating. However, both tires have their own strengths and therefore, you must choose the one that suits your driving preferences better.
When it comes to pricing, the Celsius Sport is available at an initial price of at least $150.45 per tire, while the Weathergrip is available at a starting price of $131.99 per tire. This means a set of four Celsius Sport tires will cost at least $601.80 and a set of four Weathergrip tires will cost you at least $527.96. So, this means that Celsius tires are a bit expensive than the Weathergrip tires.
Looking at SimpleScores, you should consider the Celisus Sport if you:
- Drive a luxury CUV like the Volvo XC40, an SUV like the Chevrolet Tahoe, or a wagon like the older Honda Crosstour
- Need tires that offer better handling
- Are comfortable paying slightly more for a set of tires that won’t disappoint in performance
Conversely, you should choose the Weathergrip if you:
- Drive a hybrid like the Toyota Prius, a 2-row CUV like the Honda CR-V, or a luxury CUV like the Honda CR-V
- Need tires that are better in traction
- Need tires that are better in longevity
Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents will be more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.