Compare
Free shipping
Best price guarantee
Special pricing
Financing with Resolve
Easy returns
Last updated 3/11/2025 - Originally published 3/11/2025
Written by SimpleTire, Expertly reviewed by Brett Antosh
Pirelli and Toyo are two of the most well-known tire manufacturers, each recognized for producing high-quality tires. While Pirelli is one of the largest global tire producers, Toyo is equally reputable for delivering reliable and performance-driven products. Both brands offer a wide range of tires for passenger cars, CUVs, SUVs, and light trucks, covering categories such as all-season, highway, all-weather, all-terrain, winter, and ultra-high-performance. For those looking for an all-terrain tire, Pirelli’s Scorpion All Terrain Plus and Toyo’s Open Country A/T III stand out, delivering excellent performance on challenging terrains.
Designed for Jeeps, SUVs, 4x4s, and pickup trucks, the Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus and Toyo Open Country A/T III are two of the best options in the all-terrain tire category as they offer superb traction, grip, stability, durability, and longer service life. With special rubber compounds, both tires offer increased resistance to cuts, chips, and snags, leading to extra durability. So, which one to go for? To help you ease your buying decision and pick the perfect tire for your vehicle, let’s compare Pirelli Dueler AT Revo 3 vs Toyo Open Country A/T III based on our proprietary SimpleScore.
Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus tires
The Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus introduced in 2018 as the successor to the Scorpion ATR, is designed to excel in both on- and off-road driving. Pirelli ensures a premium driving experience by incorporating low tread noise, optimized self-cleaning capabilities, and enhanced traction on wet, mud, gravel, and sandy surfaces.
The Scorpion All Terrain Plus is Three Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) certified, making it a reliable choice for moderate to severe winter conditions. Additionally, it offers damage resistance, a comfortable ride, and long-lasting tread life, making it a solid option for all-terrain enthusiasts.
With strong traction, enhanced handling, and excellent tread wear resistance, the Scorpion All Terrain Plus has earned a commendable SimpleScore of 8.4.
Get Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus tires at the best deals for your vehicle here
Toyo Open Country A/T III tires
Introduced in 2020, the Toyo Open Country A/T III has an aggressive tread pattern for increased off-road performance and it’s optimized to resist noise and vibrations for a quiet and comfortable ride when driven on paved roads. The use of advanced rubber compound not only enables the Toyo to handle wet and snow more confidently but also restricts cuts, chips, and snags for improved durability. While lateral grooves, stone ejectors, and 3D multi-wave sipes enhance traction on dry, wet, and snowy surfaces, the wide void areas of the Open Country A/T III allow quick removal of water, dirt, mud, slush, and sand out of the tread for effective traction. Backed by an up to 65,000-mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, the Toyo is Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified for great performance in moderate to severe snow and ice.
Scoring better than the Pirelli, the Toyo’s 9.3 average SimpleScore underlines its impeccable grip, braking, acceleration, stability, steering response, and durability.
Get Toyo Open Country A/T III tires at the best deals for your vehicle here
Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus vs Toyo Open Country A/T III tires on traction
A tire’s traction ensures the vehicle maintains its grip on the road, preventing skidding even at high speeds. Poor traction can compromise safety, making it a key factor in the tire selection process.
The Scorpion All Terrain Plus with a solid 8.7 in traction delivers reliable on- and off-road grip. Its large, irregular blocks with sharp edges enhance traction on slippery surfaces, ensuring maximum control in off-road conditions. The high-density siping boosts grip in dry, wet, and snowy conditions, while the groove cones promote self-cleaning for better traction. As a Three Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) certified tire, it offers dependable traction in moderate to severe winter weather.
Dominating in traction, the Toyo Open Country A/T III boasts an outstanding 9.8 SimpleScore. Its innovative tread pattern and staggered shoulder lugs deliver excellent wet braking and exceptional off-road performance. The strategically spaced blocks efficiently clear slush, water, and mud, ensuring consistent traction across terrains. The Toyo Open Country A/T III is also 3PMSF certified and offers exceptional grip in moderate to severe winter conditions, making it a top contender in all-terrain traction.
The clear difference in SimpleScores crowns the Toyo Open Country A/T III the winner in traction tuffle. Both tires are 3PMSF certified and will deliver solid traction on all terrains and in all weather conditions.
ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country A/T III
Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus vs Toyo Open Country A/T III tires on handling
Whether you're driving with ultra-high-performance or all-terrain tires, steering response directly impacts vehicle control. That’s why handling is a key aspect to consider when choosing the right tire. Let’s see how these two contenders compare.
The Scorpion All Terrain Plus delivers an impressive 8.5 SimpleScore in handling. Its solid shoulder blocks enhance stability and sturdiness, maintaining the tire’s shape for quick, agile movements on highways and rugged terrains. The irregular blocks with sharp edges provide enhanced control in off-road conditions, ensuring better grip on slippery surfaces. High-density siping further improves ride control, optimizing performance in dry, wet, and snowy conditions. Additionally, its wider footprint boosts stability and steering response, keeping drivers in full control.
Easily edging out its competitor, the Toyo Open Country A/T III secures an outstanding 9.3 SimpleScore in handling. Its advanced rubber compound enhances steering response in both dry and wet conditions, while the optimized void area and reinforced block rigidity further contribute to precise handling and overall driving stability.
The Toyo tire scores another win with an excellent SimpleScore of 9.3 against 8.5 of Scorpion All Terrain Plus.
ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country A/T III
Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus vs Toyo Open Country A/T III tires on longevity
Tire longevity refers to the number of miles or years a tire can last, but it depends on several factors, including driving habits, weather conditions, and road surfaces.
With a solid 8.4 SimpleScore, the Scorpion All Terrain Plus is built for durability. Its optimized tread design ensures even contact pressure distribution, promoting extended mileage. Groove cones prevent debris buildup, protecting the tread from damage and extending tire life. Additionally, the reinforced shoulder blocks enhance overall durability, reducing wear and tear for long-lasting performance. Backed by Pirelli’s 50,000-mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, this tire is engineered to go the extra mile.
Outperforming its competitor, the Open Country A/T III achieves an impressive 8.9 SimpleScore for longevity. This is due to stone ejectors that minimize stone drilling, 3D multi-wave sipes that reduce uneven tread wear, and an optimized void ratio for uniform wear performance. Toyo also provides an up to 65,000-mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty (50,000 miles for LT-metric sizes), making it a great choice for long-term reliability.
The Toyo tires score a win in longevity as well, ensuring an overall better performance than its competitor.
ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country A/T III
When to use each
All-terrain tires are a good option for SUV and light truck owners looking for occasional off-road drives. They feature reinforced sidewalls and sturdy carcasses for extra durability and a longer service life. All-terrain tires are excellent for driving both on and off the road, but if you only plan to stick to highways and paved roads with your trucks and SUVs, you can go for highway terrain tires.
Which one should you choose?
To sum up, the Toyo Open Country AT III wins the traction, handling, and longevity battles while the Scorpion All Terrain Plus has an edge in brand reputation. For warranty, the Pirelli has a lesser coverage (50,000 vs 65,000 miles) compared to the Toyo. Let’s check their prices to see which is the real deal.
For the LT265/70R17 size, the Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus costs $253.96 per tire, while its set of four tires costs $1,015.84. Similarly, the Toyo Open Country A/T III costs $276.26 per tire, while its set of four tires costs $1,105.04.
You should pick the Scorpion All Terrain Plus if you:
- Drive a full-size SUV like the Chevrolet Tahoe, a full-size pickup truck like the Ford F-150, or a heavy-duty truck like the Dodge RAM 2500
- Need tires that offer enhanced ride comfort
- Want a more affordable tire that also delivers confident performance in all avenues
You should go for the Toyo Open Country A/T III if you:
- Drive vehicles like the Toyota 4Runner, Chevrolet Silverado 1500, Jeep Cherokee, and GMC Yukon
- Want increased traction (9.8 vs 8.7), handling (9.3 vs 8.5), and longevity (8.9 vs 8.4)
- Prefer a tire with a longer mileage warranty (65,000 vs 50,000 miles)
- Are willing to pay more for a better set of tires
Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.