Compare
Free shipping
Best price guarantee
Special pricing
Financing with Resolve
Easy returns
Last updated 12/10/2024 - Originally published 12/10/2024
Written by SimpleTire
For daily drivers and off-road enthusiasts, Atturo comes out as a value-offering tire manufacturer with an experience of over 80 years in the business. In the light truck and SUV tire replacement market, Atturo is a well-known brand and its range of mud-terrain, rugged-terrain, and all-terrain tires perfectly fulfill the price point yet performance-driven expectations of tire seekers.
Kanati, on the other hand, is part of Greenball Corporation and has been in the tire business for over 44 years. Headquartered in Anaheim, CA, Kanati specializes in making quality tires for light trucks, Jeeps, SUVs, and ATVs/UTVs. With off-road performance at its core, Kanati is also highly admired by enthusiasts looking for performance-worthy choices at affordable prices.
Shortlisted for the comparison here are the two worthy tires from Atturo and Kanati – the Trail Blade X/T and the Terra Commander RTX! Both are suitable for use on light trucks and SUVs and fall in the rugged-terrain tire category. Rugged terrain tires are a great blend of all-terrain tires and mud-terrains. They can be used on- and off-road, like all-terrain tires, and off-the-road, like mud-terrain tires. However, their ability to drive in off-road conditions is typically better than the all-terrain tires.
Utilizing our proprietary tire rating system, SimpleScore, we will compare Trail Blade X/T vs Terra Commander RTX tires to understand their overall performance abilities and how they fare in traction, handling, and longevity. So, let’s compare these Atturo and Kanati rugged terrain tires and learn more about them!
Atturo Trail Blade X/T tires
Atturo Trail Blade X/T was launched in November 2022 and is a great hybrid tire offering the best of both MT and AT tires. Bigger mud-terrain shoulder blocks, rough sidewall, and all-terrain kind of center tread pattern make it quite a comprehensive choice for adventurers with daily driving aspirations. Atturo has put in efforts to make the tire quieter, traction-worthy, quick in response, stable, and adaptive to both rain as well as light snow conditions. All these great qualities award the Trail Blade X/T an overall SimpleScore rating of 7.7.
Kanati Terra Commander RTX tires
Kanati Terra Commander RTX has been on the market for 3 years and allows the drivers of SUVs or pickup trucks to comfortably cruise on the highways as well as handle occasional off-road-adventures. Kanati has optimized the tire for quieter and smoother rides, increased grip and traction, as well as strength and stability. It is mud and snow rated for optimum performance in these conditions and thanks to the aforementioned abilities, the Terra Commander RTX scores an overall 8.4 SimpleScore rating.
Atturo Trail Blade X/T vs Kanati Terra Commander RTX tires on traction
As we compare rugged-terrain tires, analyzing their traction performance becomes relatively important as it helps tire buyers gauge how well they perform in on- and off-road conditions. When we compared the Trail Blade X/T and Terra Commander RTX tires, there was a big difference in their scores.
Commencing with the Trail Blade X/T, the tire scores a 7.5 SimpleScore rating in traction, which indicates that the tire can perform in both paved as well as rough conditions. It is not a Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified tire but is adequately loaded with features to boost traction and grip. The tread blocks of the tire feature alternating sipes that improve snow traction and then the larger shoulder blocks that we typically see in mud-terrain tires ensure solid off-road traction. The angled shoulder grooves of the Trail Blade X/T boost traction on trails, while center tread blocks improve traction in rain and snow.
Contrarily, the Terra Commander RTX tire scores an 8.4 SimpleScore rating in traction and indicates a great on- and off-road performance. The credit goes to the optimized tread design that features closely placed lugs that improve contact with the surface. The stone ejectors remove rocks and other debris to ensure that maximum grip is maintained during off-road driving. There are sipe lugs that provide extra grip in off-road conditions and the Mud and Snow (M+S) rating further confirms the tire’s great utility in muddy and light snow environments.
While the Trail Blade X/T is certainly good with its traction abilities, it is the Terra Commander RTX that offers traction performance at par with some of the best tires on the market, thus leading in the traction analysis race here.
ADVANTAGE: Kanati Terra Commander RTX
Atturo Trail Blade X/T vs Kanati Terra Commander RTX tires on handling
How do the Trail Blade X/T and Terra Commander RTX tires respond to the driver’s command, steer in different conditions, and perform on the stability and lane change fronts? Let’s get to know about it. To mention, a slight difference was observed in the handling scores as well.
The Trail Blade X/T scores an impressive 7.9 SimpleScore rating in handling. There are horizontal and vertical sipes for noise reduction and improved handling in snow conditions. The large shoulder blocks and flat footprint provide optimum stability to the tire whether driving on highways or chasing the trails.
Modestly angled shoulders contribute to smoother handling performance, while the center blocks are linked together at their base stability on the highways. The footprint with smaller blocks at the center reduces noise and enhances traction and handling in snow or rain.
On the other hand, the Terra Commander RTX scores an 8.4 SimpleScore in the handling area, confirming the tire’s great ability to steer, maneuver, and timely respond to the driver’s steering commands. The tire is optimized for comfortable cruising on open highways and light off-road conditions. The broad shoulders and aggressive sidewalls of the tire help in enhancing stability and cornering. For driving pleasure on paved roads and highways, the optimized void ratio reduces the tread noise levels. In contrast, the sipes on the tread blocks provide extra surefootedness for confident maneuvering on roads and slick conditions.
In the handling area as well, it is the Kanati Terra Commander RTX that surpasses the Atturo Trail Blade X/T’s performance.
ADVANTAGE: Kanati Terra Commander RTX
Atturo Trail Blade X/T vs Kanati Terra Commander RTX tires on longevity
Let’s talk about the long-lasting factor now as it indicates how long a tire can service. When we compared the longevity scores of both tires, we found that the gap in their scores was lowest here.
Starting with the Trail Blade X/T, it scores a great 8.2 SimpleScore rating, confirming the tire’s long-lasting performance. The limited manufacturer tread life warranty of 45,000 miles adds more value to the long-lasting factor, ensuring that at least up to 45K miles the drivers can go on- and off-road worry-free. The sturdy “Knife Blade” tread blocks ensure damage resistance, while the rim guard protects wheels and sidewalls from curb damage. The open shoulders and blocky tread pattern prevent the casing from damage, offering longer tread life.
On the contrary, the Terra Commander RTX tire scores an 8.4 SimpleScore rating in longevity. Thanks to the aggressive tread pattern that resists driving and off-roading pressures to contribute to a long-lasting tread life. Similarly, the reinforced 3-ply sidewalls are engineered to prevent the wheel and tire from damage. The stone ejectors between the lugs also provide optimum damage resistance to the tire. Additionally, the tire is backed by a 45,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty like its rival, assuring that the buyers do not need to worry in the long run about the tire’s service.
The longevity analysis indicates that the Terra Commander tires come out as a winner, leaving the Trail Blade tires behind in the race.
ADVANTAGE: Kanati Terra Commander RTX
When to use each
Both tires are good for off-road and on-road driving and feature an all-season tread compound that makes them good for year-round use in dry, wet, and light snow conditions. However, none of the tires are Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified and therefore, shouldn’t be considered for driving in moderate to severe winter conditions in temperatures below 45 degrees Fahrenheit. If you’re looking for a tire specifically for off-road purposes, consider a set of mud-terrain tires and if you drive more on the highways and very occasionally go off-the-road, all-terrains could also be a good choice.
When it comes to tire sizes, the Trail Blade X/T tires are offered in 14- to 26-inch rim size options, offering a good number of compatibility choices. On the other hand, the Terra Commander RTX tires are offered in 17- to 20-inch rim size options.
Which one should you choose?
Looking at the overall SimpleScores, we found that the Terra Commander RTX tires score higher than the Trail Blade X/T tires (8.4 vs 7.7 SimpleScore rating). In addition, the Terra Commander also surpassed the Trail Blade in areas like traction, handling, and longevity, coming out as a reliable choice. However, both tires have one or the other strong areas that you must evaluate before making a purchase.
Regarding pricing, the Trail Blade X/T is offered at a starting price of at least $127.98, while the Terra Commander RTX is available at a starting price of at least $126.99 per tire. This means a set of four Trail Blade X/T tires will cost you $511.92, while a set of four Terra Commander RTX tires will cost you at least $507.96.
Looking at the SimpleScore, you should consider the Trail Blade X/T if you:
- Drive a heavy-duty pickup truck like the Ford F-350 or anything like the GMC Yukon XL
- Need a set of tires that’s admired for its off-road performance
- Need a set of tires that looks more stylish
- Need a set of tires that’s compatible with a larger set of vehicles on the market
On the other hand, you should choose the Terra Commander RTX if you:
- Drive an off-road specific SUV like the Jeep Wrangler or a full-size pickup truck like the Chevrolet Silverado 1500
- Need a set of tires that’s better in traction
- Need a set of tires that’s better in handling
- Need a set of tires that’s better in longevity
Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, and our agents will be more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.