I labeled Winter as N/A because we have not gotten snow yet. Comfort is a 4 instead of a 5 just because they feel a little floaty, the truck has a little more lane wander after throwing these tires on but its nothing that really bothers me. I also labeled "noise" as N/A because I love having tire noise, I don't think these make too much but I really don't notice it. So far I have had them offroad in gravel, rocky, and grassy terrain. I also run them every day on the highway with no complaints, my fuel mileage has gone down a little since putting them on but they are more aggressive than the tires I had before. I just pulled out my boat the other day, usually would have to use 4wd due to the wet boat landing and the weight of the boat but these tires pulled just fine in 2wd no slipping. I have put around 6,000 miles on the tires and the tread is holding up well.